US modern soda sales rise 83% to $1.8bn
Walmart introduced the modern soda concept five years ago, helping establish a dedicated retail destination for drinks combining conventional soda formats with better-for-you positioning. Brandt Maybury, co-founder and managing director of Tastehead, describes the category as bringing together existing developments in premium drinks and sugar reduction, often supplemented by functional ingredients. These include electrolytes, antioxidants, prebiotics and collagen. Mintel found that 40% of American carbonated soft-drink introductions carried functional claims during the year ending September 2026, the highest proportion it had recorded. Prebiotics accounted for much of that activity. In Mintel’s 2026 consumer research, 19% of carbonated soft-drink consumers had drunk functional sodas, including Olipop and poppi, compared with 51% who had consumed regular, full-calorie products such as Coca-Cola or Pepsi. Functional soda consumption reached 29% among people aged 16-34.
Tastewise’s analysis of American social-media, menu and online retail data indicates a shift in purchasing motivations. Its August 2025-September 2026 analysis put health-related motivation below 4%, following an approximately 23% annual decline. Fun accounted for around 5%, an increase of roughly 9% from a year earlier. Refreshment was broadly unchanged at approximately 5%, while nostalgia accounted for about 3%. Tastehead’s focus groups found that people seeking healthier soft drinks consistently placed sugar reduction ahead of other health benefits, but differed over ingredients. Some preferred no sugar; others favoured a small quantity rather than sweeteners. Objections extended to both artificial and natural sweeteners, reflecting taste preferences and perceptions of ingredients. Agave and coconut sugar attracted similarly divided responses. Erica Grundish, poppi’s general manager, said packaging and cultural visibility encouraged curiosity, ingredients prompted trial, and flavour supported repeat purchases.
Gut-health positioning remains prominent in product development. Innova Market Insights found such claims on 69% of American modern soda launches; 57% of consumers across the United States and Canada said they were trying to increase fibre consumption for digestive health. Tastewise counted 21 American carbonated soft-drink introductions featuring prebiotics during the preceding 12 months, compared with six featuring postbiotics and four highlighting fibre. Maybury attributed prebiotics’ popularity partly to the relative ease of incorporating them without substantial changes to flavour, texture or ingredient costs. Mimi Bonnett, senior director of insights at Innova Market Insights, identified opportunities in nutritional benefits beyond digestion, including protein and fibre. Tastehead reported rapidly increasing demand for protein, although incorporating it into acidic beverages presents manufacturing difficulties. Other ingredients attracting attention include collagen, adaptogens and nootropics, alongside formulations targeting mood or concentration. Alex Beckett, principal strategist at Mintel Food and Drink, cautioned brands about consumer scepticism towards benefit claims, particularly those concerning mood.
Tastewise’s comparison of beverage signals over August 2024-July 2026 assigned modern soda an approximately 0.10% share, with growth of 9%. Full-sugar soda accounted for 4.5%, growing 8%; diet soda represented 5.8%, with 28% growth; and zero-sugar soda held 4.8%, increasing 8%. Sparkling water registered 0.6%, with a 10% decline. The measures track social, menu and retail-shelf activity. Tastewise grouped prebiotic and functional sodas, together with Olipop and poppi, within modern soda. Its share rose from approximately 0.07% in September 2024 to about 0.10% in July 2026. On these measures, modern soda was around one fifty-eighth the size of diet soda, one forty-fifth that of full-sugar soda and one forty-eighth that of zero-sugar soda. Miriam Aniel Oved, a senior consumer trends analyst at Tastewise, said its month-to-month movements generally followed those of full-sugar and zero-sugar soda. Across the 23-month period, Tastewise found no consistent pattern of modern soda increasing as another soda category declined.
Retail distribution is extending beyond specialist discovery into mainstream shopping. Tastewise found modern soda disproportionately popular among convenience-store shoppers, including customers of Speedway, Casey’s, Kwik Trip and Circle K. Maybury said relatively modest production requirements also make the category accessible to new brands. Some third-party beverage manufacturers accept orders of just 1,000 litres, whereas obtaining comparably small runs of extruded snacks or industrial confectionery can be harder. Functional ingredients generally present fewer structural and textural difficulties in liquids than in baked goods or confectionery, he added. The possibility of a lengthy shelf life at ambient temperatures is another manufacturing advantage. Walmart’s early adoption provided brands with an established in-store location for the category.
Smaller businesses have supplied much of the innovation, according to Maybury, while large beverage companies have responded through acquisitions and product launches. PepsiCo bought Poppi and introduced Pepsi Prebiotic Cola; Coca-Cola entered through Simply Pop. Grundish said poppi saw opportunities to expand into stadiums, university campuses and other places where consumers already drink soda. She described modern soda as already establishing a third position alongside conventional full-calorie and diet products. Oved offered a more qualified interpretation, saying Tastewise’s data did not settle whether the products constituted a separate segment. She identified scale as a challenge, given modern soda’s much smaller tracked presence and growth rates broadly similar to those of full-sugar and zero-sugar drinks.
Maybury expects demand to involve several types of consumption: replacing an existing soda, choosing modern soda instead of water, juice or kombucha, or adding another drink during the day. He also expects greater overlap between diet, functional and energy drinks, citing the British brand PerfectTed’s matcha-based energy products as an example of a different approach to energy-drink occasions. Grundish said conventional full-calorie and diet varieties would retain their place while modern soda offered another reason to choose a soft drink. On competition, Maybury expects brands to devote greater attention to sensory qualities, with better-tasting formulations more likely to retain consumers. The article also identifies price and availability as factors affecting the category’s further development.
