General Mills Completes Transition to Natural Dyes in Cereals, Highlighting Industry Challenges
General Mills has successfully eliminated synthetic dyes from its U.S. cereal brands, completing a highly observed industry commitment. This move now includes 90% of its U.S. retail products, with a full transition planned by the end of 2027 for its fruit snacks and baking products. The change is part of a wider industry trend that aims to replace petroleum-based dyes with plant-based alternatives, which involve a complex transformation of the supply chain rather than a simple reformulation.
A report by RTI International, commissioned by the National Confectioners Association (NCA), highlights that while companies race to meet 2027 commitments, the demand for non-FD&C (Federal Food, Drug, and Cosmetic Act-certified) colorants could surge by 400% to 500%. Current agricultural and processing frameworks are inadequate for this level of increase, necessitating significant investment in supply chain infrastructures, including expanding domestic production and extraction of colorant crops.
Huge multinational firms, including General Mills, Kraft Heinz, Nestlé USA, and others, have pledged to remove FD&C colors by 2027. However, the NCA report reveals that the FDA’s industry pledge tracker does not consider whether alternative ingredients are secured or factory trials have been successful, underscoring the uncertainty of meeting these targets.
In 2025, FD&C dyes appeared in products responsible for $57.8 billion in sales, with beverages, candy, and snacks as the main segments using these colorants. Color-driven brand identities play a crucial role in the commercial success of these products. Meeting demand for plant-based alternatives could require ten times the amount of colorant compared to synthetic dyes, emphasizing the potential supply shortages.
Companies like Sensient Technologies are responding by investing up to $250 million to expand natural-color manufacturing. The growing dependency on imports for colorant crops such as annatto and saffron from countries like China and India adds an extra layer of complexity to the issue. Michael Kreutzer of Oterra US suggests that larger manufacturers have a strategic advantage in securing both supply and expertise as demand for natural colors intensifies.
The RTI study modeled several demand scenarios suggesting dramatic price increases for non-FD&C colorants if demand is accelerated as projected. For example, curcumin could see price hikes of up to 3,200% under extreme demand increases. Imports are expected to bear much of the burden as domestic supply grows slowly.
The report emphasizes the need for coordinated efforts across the supply chain and regulatory environment to manage the transition efficiently. It warns of shortages and cost surges without adequate preparation, suggesting strategic approaches such as increasing precision fermentation, securing long-term contracts, and implementing stable regulatory standards.
