Four US states consider caffeine warnings with different thresholds and coverage
Federal rules require conventional packaged foods to list separately added caffeine among their ingredients, without specifying its quantity. Supplements generally must quantify caffeine declared as an individual dietary ingredient. However, caffeine supplied through botanicals—including coffee, guarana, green tea and yerba mate—or proprietary blends may not receive a separate total-caffeine declaration. Covered restaurant chains must provide calories and specified nutritional information, but federal menu rules do not require caffeine disclosures. In June 2026, FDA added proposed guidance on caffeine-content labeling for foods and beverages to its Human Foods Program agenda. Guidance cannot impose binding labeling obligations or establish a mandatory national standard. Caffeine sold in conventional foods, supplements and over-the-counter stimulant medicines is subject to different quantitative disclosure and warning requirements.
New Jersey's Senate Bill 4183 would require covered food retailers to mark drinks providing at least 80 milligrams of total caffeine in each serving. Notices would sit beside the relevant drink on menus, including drive-through boards. Assembly Bill 3259 initially adopted that threshold, but an October 2026 committee amendment raised it to 200 milligrams and restricted coverage to restaurant chains operating at least 20 locations nationwide. The amended Assembly version excludes naturally caffeinated drinks such as coffee, tea and cocoa, covering beverages whose caffeine content has been increased beyond natural levels through intentional addition or chemical synthesis. Both bills specify first-offence fines of $200–$500, rising to $500–$1,000 for later offences. Their introduced versions expressly exclude a private right of action, preserve other claims under state law and supersede local ordinances governing these disclosures.
Pennsylvania's HB 2377, named the Sarah Katz Caffeine Safety Law, would cover beverages delivering at least 250 milligrams per serving. Amendments adopted in June 2026 increased that threshold from 80 milligrams. Retail food facilities would place the words “high caffeine”, or an alternative warning, icon or symbol authorised by the Pennsylvania Department of Agriculture, beside the drink on menus and menu boards. Existing food-safety licensing bodies would enforce the measure, issuing written notices and allowing 30 days for correction. Unresolved violations could attract sanctions under existing food-safety legislation. For facilities overseen by the Department of Agriculture, civil fines could reach $10,000 for each offence.
New York's S9158 would apply to food-service chains with at least 20 locations in the state, sharing a name and substantially similar food offerings. Items with added caffeine, or total caffeine of at least 150 milligrams per serving, would require identification. Chains would also disclose caffeine quantities in milligrams, display a specified safety notice and provide a separate menu of caffeine-free choices. For packaged foods and supplements containing more than 10 milligrams, the bill would require total-caffeine disclosure, identification of its natural or added origin, and a statement describing 400 milligrams as the recommended daily limit for healthy adults. Above 100 milligrams per serving, labels would need additional cardiovascular wording and advice against sale to under-18s. Products with added caffeine or at least 150 milligrams per serving would carry a high-caffeine designation online and in mobile applications, alongside advice against consumption by children. FDA describes 400 milligrams daily differently: for most healthy adults, it is an amount generally unassociated with adverse effects.
Delaware's House Substitute 1 for HB 396 cleared committee in June 2026. It would require food retailers operating at least 20 locations within Delaware to put warning symbols beside qualifying energy drinks and hand-crafted beverages. For hand-crafted drinks, the threshold would be more than 100 milligrams of caffeine in a serving. Drinks obtaining all their caffeine from brewed, steeped or otherwise coffee- or tea-derived sources would be excluded, as would alcoholic drinks and businesses selling alcohol. The Division of Public Health would issue written violation notices. Businesses would receive 90 days to remedy either a first or second violation.
A separate Delaware measure, House Substitute 1 for HB 394, passed the House after changes to its retail-signage provisions and is before the Senate Health & Social Services Committee. It would direct the Division of Public Health to supply warning signs for placement near energy drinks and caffeinated supplements, while encouraging retailers to display them voluntarily. The warnings address consumption by children, people sensitive to caffeine, and pregnant or nursing consumers. The original HB 394 would have barred sales to under-18s of defined energy drinks and caffeinated supplements supplying at least 100 milligrams per serving. A substitute replaced the proposed sales ban with compulsory signage; a subsequent House amendment made display voluntary.
Existing federal law distinguishes between state labeling requirements and safety warnings. Section 403A of the Federal Food, Drug, and Cosmetic Act preempts certain state ingredient and nutrition-labeling rules that differ from federal requirements. A savings provision in the Nutrition Labeling and Education Act exempts state-required warnings about food or food-component safety from that preemption. FDA also regulates “high” as a nutrient-content claim and does not allow characterising claims for substances without an established Reference Daily Intake or Daily Reference Value, including caffeine. The source analysis identifies potential preemption questions for state-mandated caffeine quantities, source declarations and high-caffeine label designations, alongside questions about whether prescribed statements meet the factual and uncontroversial standard for compelled commercial speech.
